In its order dated August 8, 2024, passed in Complaint No. CC005000000127087, Member Mahesh Pathak held that the complainants had not established a case for claiming a specific covered parking space at their preferred location or compensation from the promoter.
MahaRERA directed the promoter, Dream World Landmark LLP, to allot a car parking space in accordance with the society’s decision. It further clarified that if the complainants had any additional grievance regarding the covered parking space, they were at liberty to approach the housing society.
Background of the Case
The complainants, Anant Ram Kori and Laxmi Kori, had booked Flat No. 608, admeasuring 78.59 sq. metres carpet area, on the sixth floor of Tower E in the promoter’s registered project Godrej Prana, bearing MahaRERA Registration No. P52100001372, situated at Undri, Pune.
They had entered into a registered Agreement for Sale dated January 12, 2017, for a total consideration of ₹52,40,003.
According to the complainants, the promoter had agreed to hand over possession of the flat by December 2018, along with a grace period of 12 months. The agreement also included one covered car parking space admeasuring 12.5 sq. metres, as recorded in Clause K.
The complainants stated that ₹1,61,447 had been paid towards the covered parking space in addition to the flat consideration. They also relied upon the stamp duty valuation and Index II documents to establish that the covered parking had been included in the transaction.
The promoter subsequently issued a possession letter dated February 14, 2020, offering possession of the flat. On the same date, the promoter allocated parking space O-17 at podium P2 in Tower E.
However, when the complainants visited the project, they allegedly discovered that the allotted parking space O-17 did not exist.
Homebuyers Alleged Non-Provision of Promised Covered Parking
The complainants approached the promoter through email dated September 14, 2021, seeking clarification regarding the allocation of the parking space.
In response, the promoter informed them through an email dated October 4, 2021, that temporary parking had been provided and that the proposed multi-level car parking (MLCP) would take more than a year to construct.
The complainants alleged that the promoter had failed to provide the covered parking promised under the registered Agreement for Sale despite repeated follow-ups.
They further alleged that the promoter had created third-party rights in the parking space originally allocated to them and was avoiding its contractual obligations by citing delays in the construction of the proposed multi-level parking facility and the COVID-19 pandemic.
Accordingly, they approached MahaRERA seeking the following reliefs:
-
A direction to the promoter to provide one covered car parking space as promised under the Agreement for Sale.
-
Compensation of ₹5 lakh towards mental harassment and trauma.
-
Costs and other appropriate reliefs.
Promoter’s Defence: Society’s Decision Led to Changes in Parking Plans
The promoter, Dream World Landmark LLP, denied the allegations and contended that the complaint was without merit.
It submitted that Prana Cooperative Housing Society Ltd. had been formed and registered on January 29, 2019, and that the society had subsequently taken over the day-to-day management and maintenance of the project, including common amenities and facilities.
The promoter relied upon Clause 20.6 contained in the Agreements for Sale executed with other allottees. According to this clause, parking spaces were to be handed over to the association of allottees, after which the society would deal with them in accordance with its bye-laws.
The promoter further submitted that after the formation of the society, certain parking spaces marked in the original plans were considered unsuitable by the society. The society allegedly removed the markings and identification numbers of these spaces, resulting in a shortage of parking spaces.
To address the problem, the promoter proposed constructing a multi-level car parking facility.
It stated that the proposed modification required an application for correction of the sanctioned plans under Section 14(2) of the RERA Act and the requisite consent of at least two-thirds of the allottees.
The promoter also claimed that it had repeatedly requested the society to grant the necessary permission for the proposed multi-level parking facility.
Its representatives had presented the proposed plans at the society’s Annual General Meeting held on September 30, 2023. However, according to the promoter, the society had not subsequently provided its consent despite repeated follow-ups.
The promoter further submitted that temporary parking had been allotted to the complainants to avoid inconvenience until the proposed multi-level parking facility could be constructed.
It also pointed out that the complainants had not challenged the society’s decision to modify the sanctioned building plans.
MahaRERA Examines Agreement for Sale and Society’s Decision
After considering the submissions and documents placed on record, MahaRERA observed that Clause K of the registered Agreement for Sale dated January 12, 2017, clearly provided for one covered car parking space.
However, the authority noted that the agreement did not specify the particular location of the parking space.
MahaRERA observed that the complainants had initially been allotted parking space O-17 and were subsequently allotted another parking space bearing No. DE17-P-2, as reflected in the email correspondence between the parties.
The complainants, however, were insisting upon a covered parking space specifically at the P-1 and P-2 levels of Tower E.
The authority held that no such specific location was mentioned in Clause K of the Agreement for Sale.
MahaRERA also noted that the society had unanimously resolved to modify the sanctioned building plans with the requisite consent of the allottees and that the proposed changes included the construction of a multi-level parking facility.
Importantly, the complainants had not denied or challenged the promoter’s submission regarding the society’s decision by filing a rejoinder.
Consequently, the authority treated the promoter’s contention regarding the society’s decision as undisputed and unchallenged.
Society’s Decision Binding on All Members
MahaRERA observed that since the society had resolved to modify the sanctioned building plans with the requisite consent of the allottees, the complainants, being members of the same project, could not deny such modifications.
The authority specifically observed:
“The said fact cited by the respondent has not been denied by the complainants by filing any rejoinder on record of MahaRERA. Hence, the said contentions of the respondent remain undisputed and unchallenged.”
The authority further noted that Clause 20.6, relied upon by the promoter, was not included in the Agreement for Sale executed with the complainants, although it appeared in the agreements executed with other allottees.
Nevertheless, MahaRERA observed that the decision of the society was binding upon all its members, including the complainants.
The authority also considered that the promoter had allotted temporary parking to the complainants, which they had rejected because they were seeking a specific covered parking location that was not provided for in their agreement.
MahaRERA Rejects Claim for Specific Parking and Compensation
MahaRERA observed that the promoter had agreed to allot one covered parking space and had accordingly provided temporary parking to the complainants.
However, the complainants were insisting upon a specific parking location, which the authority considered impossible to provide at that stage in view of the subsequent changes to the sanctioned building plans.
The authority also noted that the complainants had not adequately explained the delay in approaching MahaRERA for the reliefs sought after obtaining possession of the flat.
Considering the facts and circumstances, MahaRERA held that there was no merit in the demand for a specific car parking space at the location insisted upon by the complainants.
Consequently, the authority also found no case for granting the compensation of ₹5 lakh claimed towards mental harassment and trauma.
Final Order
MahaRERA disposed of the complaint with the following direction:
Dream World Landmark LLP was directed to allot a car parking space in accordance with the decision of the society.
The authority further clarified that if the complainants had any additional grievance concerning the covered parking space, they were at liberty to approach Prana Cooperative Housing Society Ltd.
The complaint was accordingly disposed of by MahaRERA Member Mahesh Pathak on August 8, 2024.
Significance of the Order for Housing Societies and Homebuyers
The order highlights the importance of the registered Agreement for Sale, sanctioned building plans and decisions taken by cooperative housing societies in determining parking-related disputes.
It also demonstrates that a purchaser’s contractual entitlement to a parking space does not necessarily establish a right to insist upon a particular location when the agreement does not specify that location and subsequent modifications to the sanctioned plans have been approved through the requisite process.
For housing societies, the order highlights the importance of properly documenting decisions concerning parking arrangements and modifications to project plans.
For homebuyers, it reinforces the need to carefully examine the parking provisions in their Agreements for Sale, including the area, nature and location of the parking space, wherever specified.
The order also highlights that disputes concerning parking allocation must be examined in the context of the contractual documents, the society’s decisions and the applicable provisions of RERA.
Case Details
| Particulars | Details |
|---|---|
| Case | Anant Ram Kori and Laxmi Kori v. Dream World Landmark LLP |
| Complaint No. | CC005000000127087 |
| Authority | Maharashtra Real Estate Regulatory Authority |
| Project | Godrej Prana, Undri, Pune |
| MahaRERA Registration | P52100001372 |
| Order Date | August 8, 2024 |
| Coram | Mahesh Pathak, Member – I/MahaRERA |
| Advocates for Complainants | Aman Shukla i/b Anil D’Souza |
| Advocate for Respondent | Prabhakar Narwane |
| Decision | Complaint disposed of; parking to be allotted as per society’s decision |
Yoast SEO Settings
SEO Title
MahaRERA Rejects Demand for Specific Covered Car Parking
Focus Keyphrase
MahaRERA covered car parking dispute
Slug
maharera-covered-car-parking-dispute-godrej-prana
Meta Description
MahaRERA rejects a buyer’s demand for specific covered parking in Godrej Prana, Pune, directing the promoter to allot parking as per society’s decision.
Related Keyphrases
-
MahaRERA parking dispute
-
Covered car parking in housing societies
-
Society decision on parking allotment
-
Godrej Prana MahaRERA order
-
RERA car parking rights
Google Search Keywords
, car parking rights under RERA, covered parking Agreement for Sale, multi level car parking housing society, MahaRERA parking judgment, Section 14(2) RERA parking, parking allocation in cooperative housing societies, promoter responsibility for car parking, housing society sanctioned plan modification, car parking dispute Maharashtra, Mahesh Pathak MahaRERA
