The Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960, the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Rules, 1961, and the Model Bye-laws provide a framework for the transfer of flats and admission of new members. However, they do not expressly prescribe an interview of prospective purchasers as a mandatory condition for transferring a flat.
Is a Society NOC Mandatory for Selling a Flat?
The first point that a flat owner should understand is that a No Objection Certificate (NOC) from the Society is not mandatory for transferring a flat.
Bye-law No. 37(d) of the Model Bye-laws of Co-operative Housing Societies (2014 Model Bye-laws) specifically provides that a Society’s NOC is not required for transferring the shares and interest of the transferor to the transferee.
However, if the transferor or transferee requires an NOC, an application may be submitted to the Society, and the Managing Committee may consider the application on its merits within one month.
Therefore, a Society cannot insist that its NOC must be obtained as a precondition for executing or registering a sale agreement.
What Does Bye-law No. 37 Say About the Transfer of a Flat?
Bye-law No. 37 of the Model Bye-laws deals with the transfer of shares and interest in the capital and property of the Society.
The relevant provisions include:
1. Fifteen Days’ Notice
A member intending to transfer his or her shares and interest in the Society must give 15 days’ notice of the intention to transfer to the Secretary, along with the prescribed consent of the proposed transferee.
2. Consideration by the Managing Committee
On receiving the notice, the Secretary must place it before the next Managing Committee meeting and indicate whether the existing member is prima facie eligible to transfer the shares and interest, having regard to Section 29(2) of the MCS Act.
3. No Objection Certificate
Under Bye-law No. 37(d), an NOC from the Society is not required for transferring the shares and interest to the proposed purchaser.
4. Transfer Documents
The transferor and transferee are required to submit the prescribed transfer documents, including the application for membership, transfer application, share certificate, stamped agreement and other applicable undertakings and payments.
Thus, the Society is entitled to verify compliance with the prescribed transfer procedure. However, this does not automatically confer a right to conduct a personal interview of the proposed purchaser.
Can the Managing Committee Interview the Prospective Buyer?
Neither the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960, nor the Model Bye-laws expressly prescribe an interview of a prospective purchaser as a condition for approving the transfer of a flat or admitting the purchaser as a member.
Section 22 of the MCS Act deals with persons who may become members, while Section 23 deals with open membership.
Further, Section 154B-7 of the MCS Act provides that a transfer of shares or interest and occupancy rights in a housing society is subject to payment of the Society’s dues and the transferee applying for and acquiring membership in due course.
The Managing Committee can therefore examine whether the proposed purchaser fulfils the eligibility requirements and whether the prescribed documents have been submitted.
However, there is an important distinction between verifying eligibility and conducting an interview to judge the suitability of a purchaser.
The Committee cannot use an interview as an arbitrary screening mechanism to decide whether it personally likes the proposed purchaser or approves of the purchaser’s lifestyle, food preferences, religion, occupation or personal background.
The membership application must be considered in accordance with the Act, Rules and registered Bye-laws.
Can the General Body Pass a Resolution Making Interviews Compulsory?
This is an important aspect that deserves consideration.
Some housing societies have started introducing buyer interactions or interviews in the interest of the safety and security of existing residents. There may be instances where societies have faced unpleasant experiences involving occupants indulging in illegal or anti-social activities, thereby creating risks for other residents.
From the perspective of community safety, an interaction with a prospective purchaser may be a reasonable voluntary practice. It may help the incoming purchaser understand the Society’s rules, regulations, facilities and responsibilities.
However, a General Body resolution cannot override the provisions of the MCS Act, Rules or registered Bye-laws.
If a Society wishes to introduce a new compulsory condition affecting the rights of members and prospective purchasers, it cannot assume that merely passing a resolution at a General Body meeting makes that condition legally enforceable.
Any amendment to the registered Bye-laws must follow the prescribed procedure under Section 13 of the MCS Act and Rule 12 of the MCS Rules, including approval and registration by the competent authority.
Further, even a registered amendment must be consistent with the Act and Rules.
Therefore, a General Body resolution may provide for voluntary interactions or reasonable security-related procedures, but it cannot independently create an unrestricted power to reject a purchaser on subjective grounds or impose conditions contrary to the statutory transfer and membership provisions.
Can the Society Refuse Membership to a Prospective Purchaser?
The Society cannot arbitrarily refuse an application for membership.
Bye-law No. 39(b) of the Model Bye-laws provides that the Committee or General Body cannot refuse an application for admission to membership or transfer of shares and interest except on grounds of non-compliance with the provisions of the Act, Rules, Society Bye-laws or any other applicable law or Government order.
Further, Bye-law No. 39(c) provides that if the Society does not communicate its decision on the transfer application within three months of its receipt, the application is deemed to have been accepted and the transferee is deemed to have been admitted as a member, as provided under Section 22(2) of the Act.
Consequently, the Society cannot keep a transfer application pending indefinitely merely because the Committee wishes to interview the proposed purchaser.
Can the Society Withhold the No Dues Certificate?
A Society is entitled to recover legitimate outstanding maintenance charges and other dues payable by the existing member.
Section 154B-7 of the MCS Act specifically recognises payment of the Society’s dues as a condition relevant to the effectiveness of a transfer.
Therefore, a member intending to sell a flat should ensure that all outstanding maintenance bills and other legitimate liabilities payable to the Society are cleared.
Once the dues are paid, the member may request a No Dues Certificate or a statement confirming that no outstanding amount is payable.
The Society should provide an accurate account of the member’s dues and should not use the issuance of a No Dues Certificate as an indirect means of imposing an unauthorised buyer-interview condition.
What Should the Flat Owner Do in Such a Situation?
In the present case, the flat owner should write to the Secretary of the Society seeking clarification on the proposed interview.
The following points may be raised:
1. Request the Secretary to identify the specific provision of the MCS Act, Rules or registered Bye-laws under which the Society proposes to interview the prospective purchaser.
2. Ask whether the Society has passed any General Body resolution introducing such a procedure.
3. If such a resolution exists, request a copy of the resolution and the relevant minutes of the General Body meeting.
4. Ask whether the proposed interview is merely an introductory interaction or whether the Society intends to make the purchaser’s admission to membership conditional upon the outcome of the interview.
5. Submit the prescribed transfer documents and ensure that all legitimate Society dues are paid.
If the Society continues to obstruct the transfer or refuses to process the membership application without a legally sustainable reason, the member may approach the Deputy Registrar of Co-operative Societies having jurisdiction over the Society for appropriate relief.
Conclusion
A Co-operative Housing Society is not merely a collection of individual flats; it is a community where residents share common facilities, responsibilities and security concerns. The Managing Committee is justified in taking reasonable steps to protect the safety and interests of its members.
However, such responsibilities must be exercised within the framework of the law.
A Society may verify the identity, eligibility and documents of a prospective purchaser, and it may encourage an introductory interaction. But an interview cannot become an arbitrary test of acceptability or an additional ground for refusing membership.
In the present case, the flat owner should ask the Secretary to provide a copy of the General Body resolution, if any, under which the proposed buyer interview is being conducted. The Society should also clarify whether the interview is voluntary or compulsory and identify the legal provision supporting its decision.
Ultimately, the security of existing residents and the legal rights of an individual member to transfer his or her flat must be balanced. A Managing Committee cannot create powers for itself that the law and registered Bye-laws do not confer upon it.
