Skip to content
MCHST Site logo

MCHST

Society News for Indian States

Real Estate Ebook Banner
Primary Menu
  • Home
  • Articles
  • AD Rate Card
  • About Us
  • Contact us
  • Ask Us
  • Videos
  • Courses
  • Books
  • Judgements
Light/Dark Button
  • Home
  • Society
  • Bombay High Court Ruling on Deemed Conveyance for Housing Society
  • Land Mark Judgements
  • Legal
  • Real Estate News
  • Society

Bombay High Court Ruling on Deemed Conveyance for Housing Society

admin February 21, 2025 3 minutes read
Deemed Conveyance

The case of Veer Tower Co-operative Housing Society Limited revolves around the challenge to the dismissal of their application for deemed conveyance under Section 11 of the Maharashtra Ownership Flats (Regulation of the Promotion of Construction, Sale, Management, and Transfer) Act, 1963 (MOFA Act). The petitioner, Veer Tower Co-operative Housing Society Limited, approached the court after their application for deemed conveyance was rejected by the Competent Authority.

The petitioner argued that:

  • The developer had not utilized the full Floor Space Index (FSI), which was a crucial aspect of the redevelopment.
  • The conveyance was conditional on the complete redevelopment of all constituent societies within the project.
  • The Architect’s certificate submitted was erroneous and did not reflect the factual position.

The respondents opposed the application, claiming that:

  • The conveyance was meant to be granted in favor of a federation of societies once the entire layout plan was completed.
  • A gift deed had transferred certain rights to a Trust, allowing them to utilize the FSI.
  • The petitioner was responsible for delays in the redevelopment process.

Arguments and Responses

The respondents’ key argument was that conveyance should be granted to a federation of societies only after the layout plan was fully implemented. They highlighted the existence of a gift deed that conferred rights upon a Trust and contended that delays in redevelopment were due to the petitioner’s own inaction.

The petitioner countered these claims, stating that:

  • The Agreement for Sale represented a mutual understanding between the parties, ensuring that conveyance should not be indefinitely postponed.
  • Opposing parties cannot use procedural delays as a means to indefinitely defer the formation of a federation.
  • The Competent Authority must recognize their statutory right and issue the deemed conveyance.

The court noted that while a civil suit was pending in which the petitioner sought broader relief related to a new sanctioned plan, the existence of this suit did not negate their statutory remedy under the MOFA Act to seek deemed conveyance.

Court’s Analysis and Decision

The court ruled that the statutory right to seek deemed conveyance cannot be indefinitely deferred on the basis of redevelopment that has not yet commenced. The judgment emphasized the protection of property purchasers’ rights and the importance of upholding legal obligations under the MOFA Act.

Key observations of the court:

  • The petitioner’s right to conveyance had matured upon the execution of the agreement and the payment of consideration. Therefore, it could not be made contingent upon unverified future assurances of compliance with redevelopment obligations.
  • Delays in forming a federation or executing redevelopment plans do not negate the legal right to conveyance under the MOFA Act.
  • The rejection of the petitioner’s application for deemed conveyance was quashed.

The court directed respondent No. 1 to reconsider the application and issue a certificate of conveyance based on the Architect’s certificate. However, it clarified that any civil rights or entitlements linked to the redevelopment project could still be determined separately in the civil court.

Conclusion

This ruling reinforces the principle that statutory conveyance rights under the MOFA Act cannot be indefinitely postponed due to unexecuted redevelopment projects. It upholds the legal protections for housing society members, ensuring that property rights are not hindered by procedural delays or administrative hurdles.

Society MITR

Share

Post navigation

Previous: Bombay High Court Strikes Down MahaRERA’s “Co-Promoter” Definition in Landmark Case
Next: Supreme Court Judgment on Joint Liability in Real Estate Dispute

Related News

Housing Society Cannot Selectively Recover Legal Expenses: Court
  • Co-operative Society
  • Land Mark Judgements
  • Legal
  • Maharashtra
  • MaharashtraCo-operative Society
  • Real Estate News
  • Society

Housing Society Cannot Selectively Recover Legal Expenses: Court

admin November 4, 2026 0
Housing Society Early Payment Discount Banner
  • Co-operative Society
  • Legal
  • Maharashtra
  • MaharashtraCo-operative Society
  • Real Estate News
  • Society

Can Housing Societies Offer Discounts for Early Maintenance Payment?

admin October 31, 2026 0
Dispute Resolutions in Housing Societies
  • Co-operative Society
  • Land Mark Judgements
  • Legal
  • Maharashtra
  • Real Estate News
  • Society

Dispute Resolutions in Housing Societies

admin October 29, 2026 0

Recent

  • Housing Society Cannot Selectively Recover Legal Expenses: Court
  • Can Housing Societies Offer Discounts for Early Maintenance Payment?
  • Dispute Resolutions in Housing Societies
  • E-Voting in Redevelopment: Maharashtra 79A Guidelines Explained
  • Co-operative Courts Can Hear Internal Redevelopment Disputes: Bombay HC

You may have missed

Housing Society Cannot Selectively Recover Legal Expenses: Court
  • Co-operative Society
  • Land Mark Judgements
  • Legal
  • Maharashtra
  • MaharashtraCo-operative Society
  • Real Estate News
  • Society

Housing Society Cannot Selectively Recover Legal Expenses: Court

admin November 4, 2026 0
Housing Society Early Payment Discount Banner
  • Co-operative Society
  • Legal
  • Maharashtra
  • MaharashtraCo-operative Society
  • Real Estate News
  • Society

Can Housing Societies Offer Discounts for Early Maintenance Payment?

admin October 31, 2026 0
Dispute Resolutions in Housing Societies
  • Co-operative Society
  • Land Mark Judgements
  • Legal
  • Maharashtra
  • Real Estate News
  • Society

Dispute Resolutions in Housing Societies

admin October 29, 2026 0
E-Voting in Redevelopment: Maharashtra 79A Guidelines Explained
  • Co-operative Society
  • Legal
  • Maharashtra
  • MaharashtraCo-operative Society
  • Real Estate News
  • Society

E-Voting in Redevelopment: Maharashtra 79A Guidelines Explained

admin October 14, 2026 0

About us

Maharashtra Co-operative Housing Society Times (MCHST) — Your trusted source for housing society knowledge, legal updates, and residential redevelopment insights.

Website: www.housingsocietytimes.com

Recent Posts

  • Housing Society Cannot Selectively Recover Legal Expenses: Court
  • Can Housing Societies Offer Discounts for Early Maintenance Payment?
  • Dispute Resolutions in Housing Societies
  • E-Voting in Redevelopment: Maharashtra 79A Guidelines Explained
  • Co-operative Courts Can Hear Internal Redevelopment Disputes: Bombay HC

Most Viewed

  • Home - 58,483 views
  • New Election Rules for Housing Societies in Maharashtra - 31,772 views
  • Society’s Legal aspects - 29,679 views
  • Right to ask documents from society - 28,753 views
  • Who’s Responsible for ‘Leakage’ Repairs in societies - 13,759 views
Copyright © All rights reserved. | MoreNews by AF themes.